No More Platform Anxiety, Please [Reblog by James Scott Bell]

Ever since the word “platform” began floating around publishing circles, a whole bunch of fiction writers shuddered.  Why?  Because though we understood the importance of platform, it seemed the way to it for fiction writers, new ones especially, was going to be much, much harder than for non-fiction writers.  How do you build a platform around a series on a serial killer?  Or a quirky romantic comedy?  Or a satire? Could it be done?  Sure.  We forged our way through it.  But it was clunky. It’s still clunky.

That’s why James Scott Bell’s new article at Kill Zone caught my attention.  And then guess what?  He quotes my agent, Janet Grant.  So speaking from experience here, these are two industry pros that you can trust.

And that’s a good thing, because one of them will be at our conference, WriterCon, this Labor Day.  (Hint: he goes by Jim.) So check out some helpful information, published here with permission, on that Achilles heel of fiction writers–platform.


James Scott Bell
James Scott Bell

No More Platform Anxiety, Please by James Scott Bell

A recent post by agent Janet Kobobel Grant offers some welcome relief on the dicey subject of “platform.” I’ve been slapping that particular bongo for years. How are new fiction writers supposed to create a following before they have any books out? I even pulled up a comment I made on TZK ten years ago (before I was a contributor!), to wit:

By far and away the best “platform” for us is OTHER people yakking it up about our books. Word of mouth has always been the most powerful marketing tool. You don’t get that by blogging, tweeting or shouting. You get it ONLY by writing books people talk about. That has to be job one.

The flip side is the best promoter in the world cannot overcome a book that fizzles with the reading public. It can get you a strong introduction, but from there the book takes over. If it does fizzle, the answer is not more promotion; the answer is a stronger book.

Yet many a publisher has pushed platform building, even for unpublished writers, leading to increased levels of scribal stress and sales of Pepto-Bismol.

A platform, as the book industry sees it, is whatever you do to engage and interact with a significant portion of the public. That includes social media, blogs, vlogs, podcasts, and even good old public speaking.

All of those things take effort and cut into a writer’s creativity and productivity time. So does it make sense to spend that capital trying to create a platform at the expense of writing good books?

There is no shortcut to platform success, either. Sure, you can farm 50,000 Twitter followers, but how many of them are truly interested in you? Or you in them (shown by actual engagement)? That’s the key to social media. Thus, I was glad to read Janet’s comments:

The second group of editors I met with started off our conversation by saying they have come to realize it’s unrealistic to expect a newer novelist to have a large platform. Upon what foundation can a fiction writer build that platform? Especially as a debut novelist, you can only engage potential book-buyers so much in your writing and research endeavors before your attempted connections take on a bland sameness.

However, Janet continues, these fiction editors do want to see that a writer is “willing” to engage in platform building. Which means at least one social media footprint. The big takeaway is something I’ve advised for years:

These editors believe that choosing to focus on one aspect of social media is the best route to go. Rather than dabbling in several mediums but not really figuring out what works for you, dig into one medium and gather all your friends or followers in that one spot.

So which social media outpost is best for you? Read and reflect on Sue Coletta’s excellent post on the topic. Be sure to follow the links and also read the comments. You’ll make wiser social media choices if you do.

Janet Grant concludes:

I hope you’re taking a deep breath as you consider that some of the pressure to collect names and online connections has let up just a bit. None of these editors would say platform isn’t important. But each of them would say she—and the whole publishing team—is taking a more nuanced look at the planks of each writer’s platform.

By the way, if you want to plow right through the nuance, write a book that blows them all away. Then you can talk about platform all you want.

As I was prepping this post, an article entitled “How to Reduce Marketing Anxiety and Confusion by industry expert Jane Friedman appeared on the PW site. Jane writes, in part:

In a great scene from Lost in Translation, Bill Murray’s character says, “The more you know who you are and what you want, the less you let things upset you.” If I could customize that for today’s authors, I’d say, “The more you know who you are as an author and what readership you seek, the less confused you’ll be about marketing.” And the less you’ll be influenced by the crowd.

It’s easy to feel anxious about your progress when you see your peers engaging in new forms of publishing or marketing and you feel pressured to join. But the more you’re focused on your own long-term outcomes and how to wisely use your time and resources, the better prepared you’ll be to consider or experiment with new tactics, adopting or discarding them as you see fit.

So how is your platform anxiety these days? Does it ever detract from your writing? What are you doing about it?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


  1. Phew – I feel like I have just received official permission to stop angsting over not having an Instagram account – or even a desire to have one! On another note, I’m delighted to hear that James Scott Bell will be at WriterCon – I’m looking forward to the conference!!

  2. This came at exactly the right time for me. I am ready to start the third and final book of my first series and have been plowing deep into social media to generate a buzz. I’ve delayed starting the book because I keep thinking of things I need to do, or should do, to promote. I’ve used social media for years to promote other businesses and when I thought I had to start all over now that I am writing, I got weak in the knees. Today was a low day for that very reason. Thank you!

  3. Yes! So encouraging. I’m writing my first book (nonfiction), and have felt so uncomfortable reading what so many say is essential in order to have a chance at getting published these days. I’ve been praying for God’s direction about this, and these words help so much.